Reader Q&A: What’s the difference between Pandora and Spotify?

I feel a little embarrassed not knowing this, but can you explain the difference between Pandora and Spotify? – Shelley

You’re not the only one who’s asked us this question, Shelley, so you shouldn’t feel embarrassed! Now that there are new changes to Facebook that include integration with streaming music services, plus an overhaul to Pandora, it’s actually a good opportunity for us to compare both services and what they offer to subscribers.

Pandora

If you’re looking for a radio-type experience, then you’ll want to subscribe to Pandora, a free service that allows you to input bands, artists, or song titles in order to create a “station” filled with music similar to what you’ve selected. Keep in mind that the actual song you pick may not be played, and sometimes the choices can be a bit confusing; that’s why you might have heard people complain that they entered Coldplay and somehow a Billy Joel song popped up.

Generally though, the algorithm is pretty darn amazing, thanks to the Music Genome Project in which humans categorize millions of music tracks, not computers. When they miss, at least you can give a thumbs down to a song you don’t like and skip over it (and a couple more before you are forced to listen).

The new updated Pandora allows for much better station creation options with input of two songs or bands instead of one, which really has helped to avoid weird songs popping up. You can also now listen to 320 hours a month of music, and the new system lets you grab info on the lyrics and bands. While it’s much better designed and streamlined, with a lot more social features, the ads in the free version are definitely noticeable. So if you think you’ll get a lot of use out of Pandora, we’d definitely recommend upgrading to the pay service.

Spotify

Unlike Pandora, Spotify allows you to input specific songs and artists and listen to entire albums, more like iTunes on demand. It even syncs with your existing iTunes and MP3 playlists on your own computer. It only recently became available in the United States and only this month became open to the public, available without an invitation.

If you’re someone who likes to make your own playlists, then Spotify is probably more for you. Plus if you connect your account with Facebook, you’ll have access to all your friends’ playlists too, which actually makes life much easier if you don’t have time or energy to create your own.

A few watch-outs: the free version of Spotify does have ads, and if you connect through Facebook and agree to make your lists public, you will be showing your listening history to your friends. That might not be such a big deal, but if you’re trying to keep your Britney Spears obsession on the down low (or if all you listen to is Elmo’s Greatest Hits these days), then you might want to reconsider your privacy settings.

Both Pandora and Spotify have apps so you can listen from your mobile devices, with both having their obvious benefits and disadvantages–although it’s good to note that you don’t need to be internet connected to access your Spotify playlists. Either way, it’s fantastic to have two great options when it comes to free music listening. -Kristen

Visit the Pandora and Spotify websites to get more information about their mobile music services.

Cool Mom Staff

We spend our time looking for cool stuff so you don't have to. Hope this one fits the bill.

3 Comments

  • Reply September 28, 2011

    Jeff

    Pretty good explanation. I use both Pandora and Spotify and while Pandora was a great alternative to other free music services, I’ve almost abandoned it since Spotify appeared in the U.S. this summer. You never quite know what Pandora will give you even though you do have some control over it. Being able to listen to entire Albums or even different songs all by the same artist makes Spotify very attractive.

  • Reply October 11, 2012

    SteveP

    “you don’t need to be internet connected to access your Spotify playlists.

    This doesn’t make sense to me. You only need Spotify if you don’t already have the songs on your device. So if you have no connection, there’s no use for it. And if there’s no connection, those playlists only work for any songs that are already on your device. Again, no use for such playlists since you already have those playlists for the songs that are already on your device ….

  • Cool Mom Picks
    Reply October 12, 2012

    Cool Mom Picks

    Thanks for your comment Steve,

    You must use internet access to sync your favorite playlists, but once you have, if you are a Premium user, you can listen anywhere, even without a connection. It’s not just for your own playlists.

    http://www.spotify.com/se/help/faq/mobile/#offline-usage

Reader Comments